Now I know I am in the gross minority here, but I am going to say it. The Departed was a bad movie. Now, calm down for a second and hear me out.
Firstly, the acting was generic in my opinion- It was all one big attempt on the parts of all three leading men (and comically to a certain extent of the supporting roles) to show who had the biggest dick. This created a general wash of personality in my opinion and I didn’t really care what happened to who because I couldn’t distinguish one character from the other. Perhaps this was an artistic choice on the part of Scorsese, but if you ask me I much prefer to DISCOVER this rather than be told repeatedly. Also, I love Jack- but let’s face it, he has become a characture of himself at this point (thanks very much Witches of Eastwick)- And I don’t think doing something weird makes for good acting- It just makes it weird if the director can’t find a way to harness it’s potential within the thematic framework of the film.
Second- the screenwriting was pretty bad in my opinion as well. The premise itself is ludicrous- it basically has the same plot line as a Schwartzenegger movie (i.e. the cops spend the whole movie trying to bust the bad guy legally and then in the end just wind up shooting him negating the whole process of the chase) except this movie’s leading men take themselves way too seriously. And, I’m sorry, but I don’t think the word "fuck" should be used as a comma. It loses it’s power after the 50th time it is uttered in 10 minutes.
Lastly, the editing was terrible- I don’t usually look at this kind of thing but I found myself being constantly made aware of it with numerous jump cuts. Scorsese is no amatuer- what’s the deal?
So, overall, I think this movie is on the bottom of Scorsese’s flicks. I came to the theater excited to see something I heard was the caliber of Raging Bull, Taxi Driver, Casino, and Goodfellas- instead I saw something which I felt, in many cases, was worse than Gangs of New York.
Entries (RSS)