If any of you know me, you know that I love Ghostbusters. I LOVE IT! I have seen the original movie over 100 times (I lost count at 116 times when I was a teenager). I was actually given a copy of this movie (of which I still have) on instruction never to bring it back to said person’s house. I remember exactly where I was when I first saw a preview for Ghostbusters 2. I watched MTV religiously and waited to see the various incarnations of the Bobby Brown video to catch glimpses of Ghostbusters II before it entered the theaters. I drew pictures of the Ghostbusters symbol in my notebooks for years. Naturally, no one is more excited than I to see a new Ghostbusters film.
However, no one is as skeptical as me either. I have been let down by far too many new editions of classic films to be truly excited. Terminator 3? My God, that was depressing. Star Wars Episode I? Me and everyone else. National Lampoon’s Vegas Vacation? Sigh. So, when I heard the fab-four would be replaced by a new crew, I immediately started to worry.
Hollywood is real fond of putting no talent flavors of the month into their dynasties and effectively ruining them forever. So, Ramis and Aykroyd, if you’re reading, please consider the words of this die-hard fan. Sure they’re cheaper, but skimping on non-established talent will cost you in the end. I figure you guys are smart enough to keep a “Ghostbuster Nation” out of the film with a numerous amount of New Yorkers suddenly taking up the job as a nod to the solidarity of New York. You already did that in Ghostbusters 2 and the Spiderman Franchise has beaten that horse to death. So, it only makes sense that the original 4 will choose 4 similarly minded individuals who echo their greatness, yet bring a new sensibility and modernity to the table.
So, here are my thoughts about a new generation of Ghostbusters:
The Ray Stantz Replacement: What made Ray great was that his was the pure one. He is “the heart of the Ghostbusters.” He had a serious lack of street smarts, which was paired beautifully with vast book smarts. In many ways he was that straight A student in an Ivy League college who was the grade F student in dealing with the real world. He was also as loyal as basset hound and was ready to lash out at anyone who threatened his friends. That being said, Ray became a little too street smart in the second movie (which partially helped balance the Louis Tully character who took over the role of babe in the woods). I personally thought this was a mistake as it caused Ray to lose a lot of his charm. So, when thinking of a Ray replacement, I think the ability to play to the old Ray’s strengths is important.
1. Jack Black: Ok, I know you are already thinking about him. He is a dangerous choice in that he is always mugging for the camera. But, if you can keep him under control and keep his stupid metal-head shtick to himself, he might actually be a good choice. He does a good job of being an idiot and the science stuff might be a good piece of meat for Black to chew on in character development.
2. Sarah Silverman: We all know you are thinking about a chick Ghostbuster. Don’t pick some no-talent hottie. Aykroyd, I’m talking to you- Stay away from Eliza Dushku and Alyssa Milano. THEY ARE NOT COMEDIENNES. They are just busty Maxim girls. Keep your brain out of your pants. Now, while Ms. Silverman is attractive, she has a serious comic resume to back her up. She has that doe eyed look and dummy routine that is seriously funny. She could also speak to Ray’s more aggressive side when he is provoked in a unique and hilarious way- She could even be written in as Ray’s sister and it would be believable.
The Egon Spengler Replacement: Egon is a hard one because he is the ultimate square. He has no sense of humor (or an inhuman sense of humor that the very best). I mean this guy had part of a slinky once and he straightened it!
1. Rainn Wilson: You already have tapped Office writers, so why not look to their cast? This guy is a funny, quirky nerd who would really bring some interesting color to the character.
2. Kevin Smith: A quiet, understated comedian. Sounds like a perfect fit for the man with the huge cranium that the chicks dig.
The Winston Zeddemore Replacement: Winston needs to be the everyman. This is a guy who walked into a crazy world only because it had a steady paycheck. The person who fills this role has to have the street smarts and wit of an everyday New Yorker as well as the ability to be completely out of place in his own city thanks to his newfound job.
1. Dave Chappelle: This guy is seriously funny. Plus as a modern day everyman he would fill the Zeddemore shoes nicely while adding his own welcome flavor to role.
2. Wanda Sykes- If you have to pick a chick, pick one with some balls. Wanda Sykes is funny and she has got some serious cahones.
The Peter Venkman Replacement: Of course this is going to be the most impossible one to fill. They are some mighty big shoes. Venkman is a charlatan, a ball buster, and a loveable loser all wrapped into one. He’s a fast-talking anti-hero who rises to the challenge because he knows no one else can. He is the leader of a group who needs him sorely. But, at the same time, he needs them just as much all though he would never admit it.
1. Robert Downey Jr.: Let’s face it, the only one who is going to be able to pull something like this off is a great actor. Not some newbie. Downey Jr. is probably the most obvious choice since he has made a career on playing these types. Plus, as Tropic Thunder has proven, he is one funny guy.
2. Billy-Bob Thornton: I don’t love this guy, but he has definitely got the Venkman qualities. Perhaps he comes into the film as a disgruntled cab driver who has to help out an overwhelmed set of Ghostbusters and shows he has got the mettle to handle the positron collider?
Oscar Barrett: You got to have Oscar in this movie! He would be about 20 by now and might make an interesting and valuable addition to the movie. Part of the difficulty of casting this character will be of course, what sort of man Oscar has grown up to be. I like to think he is a bit of reflection of his father, the dorky Philharmonic from the first movie. Plus, he’s got to deal with the fact that his name is Oscar.
1. Michael Cera: He already looks like an Oscar. Would be a great side plot if he learns to be more of a man from his Uncle Peter and somehow contributes to the busters saving the day.
2. Justin Long: Skilled at playing nerds, but also a bit of a bigger guy, Long could be effective in creating a bit of a more disillusioned Oscar. Plus, it would be hilarious if somehow it was discovered that Oscar’s real father is Louis Tully and a hilarious side plot could develop from Dana having to explain that to Venkman/Louis and son learning and growing from each other’s presence. Long is also a seriously funny guy.
People who should, in no way, be considered for the roles of the main Ghostbusters:
Will Ferrell Megan Fox
Any Current Saturday Night Live Member Shia LaBeouf
The Wayans Brothers Any Musician
Maxim Chicks Eddie Murphy
Mike Myers Steve Carrell
Dane Cook
And please, for the love of all that is holy, KEEP JUDD APATOW AWAY from this movie!!!
I’m still on the fence about Seth Rogen. But he did say a 3rd Ghostbusters would be stupid, so I gotta respect that he respects a classic!